I don't know if you saw the news, but Chicago's CFO, Ashlee Gabrysch, resigned recently after only 3 months on the job. She's the third CFO to resign in the last year or so. That's an insane turnover rate.
She said she couldn't continue in the position and maintain her reputation and integrity. That might seem a bit catty until you realize who she was.
Before taking the job as Chicago's CFO, Ashlee Gabrysch was a senior director at Fitch Ratings, one of the three major credit-rating agencies. She'd been the lead analyst for Fitch covering Chicago and Illinois since 2019. She was recognized throughout the industry as a superstar.
All of that means that she knew, or thought she knew, the situation she was getting into as CFO. Her resignation letter suggests that the city has been significantly misleading everyone about the perilous state of their finances. Of all major American cities, Chicago and New York are in the worst shape in terms of their liabilities and how pressing their upcoming fiscal crises are. Chicago's pension plans are only 28% funded and they have $36B in unfunded liabilities. Their 2027 budget shows an $882M deficit. Their credit rating is a lousy BBB.
That's what they've been reporting. Her resignation letter seems to indicate that the situation is worse than that and that the city administration asked her to fudge her numbers. It's hard to come up with a reading different from that.
Compounding this is the magnitude of the change required to get the city's finances back on track. They'd need about $1.5B in a mix of budget cuts and tax increases maintained for the foreseeable future just to get on the road to recovery. Lately, tax increases have resulted in increased emigration, particularly by the wealthy and productive types. If they cut the budget, those cuts would fall almost entirely on police, fire and maintenance. Every other category of spending is either committed financially - debt servicing - or mandated by law - pensions and union benefits.
I started thinking about the next steps for the city. She's gone, so now they need to get a new CFO. What does the pool of candidate employees look like? First off, the job is staggeringly huge. Chicago is a massive city with complicated finances and rules. It's got a large bureaucracy that a new hire would have to get to know, understand their processes and then wrangle into some kind of functioning organization. That's got to be a pretty small pool of available talent.
Next, you've got the problem that, for some reason, one of the nation's top financial analysts, someone who supposedly knew the situation very well, bailed out after only 3 months, citing integrity issues. I don't care how much they pay me, I'd be running away from that job as fast as possible.
Hey, the ship's on fire, taking on water and listing 7 degrees to starboard. Wanna be the captain? We've got an opening! We offer a handsome benefits package!
On the plus side, if you took the job, you'd get to see what it was like when a city went into receivership and see it from the inside. That's got to be worth something.
Politics
It's interesting that the major cities with the worst fiscal situations both went hard left. Score one more data point for KT's hypothesis that the people fleeing the blue states and cities are the reds.
Next up: Los Angeles with Nithya Raman!








